{Grey Ghost} cartridges marked 1863

[JRD77VET]

On another forum I frequent, a guy's daughter got this at a garage sale.

What does he have? ( ten .57 paper cartridges ready to be torn open and loaded into a muzzle loader? )

[markids77]

Originally Posted by JRD77VET

On another forum I frequent, a guy's daughter got this at a garage sale.

What does he have? ( ten .57 paper cartridges ready to be torn open and loaded into a muzzle loader? )

I believe that is a reproduction, or pure fantasy construct. A quick search for CS cartridge packaging shows very different script and (of course) obvious age on the packs.

[Grey Ghost]

Wow. Part of it looks the biz. and then some of it a little suspect. The boldness of the ink '1863' where the month should be handwritten and there is a lot of debate about cart. labels after the early year of the war. Whether they were used or not and just stamped onto the paper vs a glue on label.

I know there are stamps available to reproduce labels or use on paper and the twine around the pkg.

I'll ask some others their opinion about it. Super cool either way!!!

[JRD77VET]

Originally Posted by markids77

I believe that is a reproduction, or pure fantasy construct. A quick search for CS cartridge packaging shows very different script and (of course) obvious age on the packs.

Very well could be fake. If it's real, it's in fantastic shape for being 159 years old.

[Grey Ghost]

I have one original cart. in my collection. Very fragile. I have seen arsenal packs for sale at thousands of dollars depending on arsenal or rifle type. A single cart. like I have usually goes for around $100

It's cool and I'm sure was good deal at the sale for display purposes.

Reproduction stuff is so good these days some dealers won't even buy belt buckles. There is one place that melts down original CW period red brass and has molds made from original buckles. They will make you one for $300.

[allthrottleandsomebottle]

yea..hum............these are some of my 1895 marked cartridges. They should be similar to the other pic

[allthrottleandsomebottle]

If they paid 5 or 10 bucks.....still worth it especially if you can load it and fire if modern enough!

[Grey Ghost]

Originally Posted by allthrottleandsomebottle

yea..hum............these are some of my 1895 marked cartridges. They should be similar to the other pic

Are those labels on yours or a stamp?

[allthrottleandsomebottle]

stamp I believe based on the other info on the boxes