I'll be one of the dissenters here and say you are definitely not overchicked. You're a good man and you deserve a great gal to be with. And someone who can rock a 1-piece like that? Totally friggin' sexy. I'm very happy for you.
I've used POF many times. Problem is that being a free site, you get a lot of riff-raff. You really have to fine tune the vetting process and always be ready to punch out at the first sign of crazy. I have a profile on there now but it's hidden as I'm not really in the mood to date at this time. Match is generally regarded as the best sight to be on, but it seems like you've found a real gem.