The Vette Barn

The Vette Barn (https://www.thevettebarn.com/forums/index.php)
-   Off Topic (https://www.thevettebarn.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=38)
-   -   Here's a question (cameras) (https://www.thevettebarn.com/forums/showthread.php?t=127705)

Aerovette 01-23-2022 5:46pm

Here's a question (cameras)
 
Why is it I can log on to the boarding kennel and watch my dog any time I want, but parents can't log in to their kid's classroom and see what is going on?

It would be very simple to have a camera with sound in every room and have parents drop in on their kid's classes and see what is being taught and how they are behaving.

Talk about a tool to keep kids in line.

Rodnok1 01-23-2022 5:51pm

Problem is privacy issues at public schools, plus can you imagine all the Karen's bitchin about every little thing happens in classroom. Few states/districts allow cameras and only viewed if an issue comes up.

Aerovette 01-23-2022 5:58pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by Rodnok1 (Post 1936264)
Problem is privacy issues at public schools, plus can you imagine all the Karen's bitchin about every little thing happens in classroom. Few states/districts allow cameras and only viewed if an issue comes up.

What is the difference if they see it, or their kid comes home and tells them? Karens will be Karens regardless. If anything, it will prompt BOTH to keep in line. Teachers and students.

What is the privacy issue? Some creeper logging in? Only the parents "should" have the log in and creepers can see kids on Twitter, TikTok, etc.

Rodnok1 01-23-2022 6:20pm

Combination of laws and contracts with teachers unions from what I understand, differs by state.
I don't see the need to view classrooms constantly myself, the overhead from constant complaints and inquiries would drown a district also. People would file assault charges if Bobby pushed Billy type of PC bullshit also.

Aerovette 01-23-2022 6:52pm

Access is constant, but there could be times when no one is even logged in. Poi t being that the kids and the teachers don't know if anyone is watching or not. Just like a store. You see the camera, but you don't know if anyone is monitoring or not.

As for kid A pushing kid B, it's exactly the same as if the kid tells his parents...but with evidence.

MadInNc 01-23-2022 7:21pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by aerovette (Post 1936269)
Access is constant, but there could be times when no one is even logged in. Poi t being that the kids and the teachers don't know if anyone is watching or not. Just like a store. You see the camera, but you don't know if anyone is monitoring or not.

As for kid A pushing kid B, it's exactly the same as if the kid tells his parents...but with evidence.

Are you a creeper? Is that why?

Aerovette 01-23-2022 8:05pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by MadInNc (Post 1936273)
Are you a creeper? Is that why?

Is that what you got out of the posts?

:wtf:

BayouCountry 01-23-2022 8:13pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by aerovette (Post 1936263)
Why is it I can log on to the boarding kennel and watch my dog any time I want, but parents can't log in to their kid's classroom and see what is going on?

It would be very simple to have a camera with sound in every room and have parents drop in on their kid's classes and see what is being taught and how they are behaving.

Talk about a tool to keep kids in line.

More like a tool to keep teachers in line.

BayouCountry 01-23-2022 8:14pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by MadInNc (Post 1936273)
Are you a creeper? Is that why?

Why would that even enter your mind?

Aerovette 01-23-2022 8:16pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by BayouCountry (Post 1936287)
More like a tool to keep teachers in line.

Certainly that. :seasix:

I remember the days when a paddle hung near the teachers desk and they really didn't have to use it. It was knowing they COULD that mattered to the majority. Same would go for a camera...with the benefit of hearing teachers trying to pass their ideology subtly or openly and being able to witness it first hand.

Rodnok1 01-23-2022 8:30pm

I don't get the keep teachers in line... If you don't trust the teachers/school why are you sending them there period. When I stopped trusting the school my kid didn't go anymore. Wasn't a hard decision. Yes or no not well maybe.

Aerovette 01-23-2022 8:39pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by Rodnok1 (Post 1936293)
I don't get the keep teachers in line... If you don't trust the teachers/school why are you sending them there period. When I stopped trusting the school my kid didn't go anymore. Wasn't a hard decision. Yes or no not well maybe.

If you have been watching the news at all for the last year, you'll see stories in nearly every state about CRT, you'll see stories of students beating up teachers, stories of assaulted girls in classrooms, threats of bringing guns to school. Most parents work all day and trust that their kids are being taken care of. This system would allow them to pop in and be sure.

As I said in the original post, people can watch their DOG all day in a kennel, but not their kids. My boss can watch what every employee is doing, but not his kids. Every store, airport, car lot, bank, etc. has cameras monitoring what goes on, but the thing more precious than cars, money, merchandise...it's dropped off with a pat on the head, and fingers crossed all day that they don't get mind ****ed by a teacher, beat up by a bully, or whatever. I don't have that kind of confidence in our school systems as they exist today. A thousand watchdogs or potential watchdogs, would help.

BayouCountry 01-23-2022 8:50pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by Rodnok1 (Post 1936293)
I don't get the keep teachers in line... If you don't trust the teachers/school why are you sending them there period. When I stopped trusting the school my kid didn't go anymore. Wasn't a hard decision. Yes or no not well maybe.

Many don't have the means to switch schools. My daughter is fortunate enough to be able to send her kids to private school. During her school years, she was one of the few who called out teachers asking for sources of their left wing rhetoric. She told me the class would shout her down. We would just laugh at the teachers when she told me about it. I guess it's no laughing matter anymore.

Scissors 01-23-2022 8:51pm

Some points to consider:
- Schools can't even implement simple remote learning effectively, and now we'd be expecting them to afford, install, maintain, and (most importantly) secure surveillance technology?
- Given that it would almost certainly be implemented in an insecure manner, do we really want creepers to have the power to view which kids are in class at certain times; additionally gathering intel on who's not there (and therefore might be an "alone at home" target)?
- How would this be more effective for monitoring teacher and/or class performance or acquiring evidence than a simple closed-circuit system of recorded classes, available as video with audio after a given minimum timeframe if someone with a material interest files a request?
- Is a surveillance state what we want to raise the next generation to be comfortable with?
- Do we need yet another government project that will (if history is any indication) will be implemented poorly and cost taxpayers far more money than it should?

Instead of starting with a solution in search of a problem, maybe we should take a step back, start with a specific problem, and then consider a variety of solutions for that problem that do not themselves make things worse overall. Which problem are we looking to address? Teacher performance? Student performance/behavior? Classroom cleanliness? Assurance of conformance to curriculum? Improvement of evidence quality relating to classroom-based incidents?

Aerovette 01-23-2022 10:28pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by Scissors (Post 1936299)
Some points to consider:
- Schools can't even implement simple remote learning effectively, and now we'd be expecting them to afford, install, maintain, and (most importantly) secure surveillance technology?
- Given that it would almost certainly be implemented in an insecure manner, do we really want creepers to have the power to view which kids are in class at certain times; additionally gathering intel on who's not there (and therefore might be an "alone at home" target)?
- How would this be more effective for monitoring teacher and/or class performance or acquiring evidence than a simple closed-circuit system of recorded classes, available as video with audio after a given minimum timeframe if someone with a material interest files a request?
- Is a surveillance state what we want to raise the next generation to be comfortable with?
- Do we need yet another government project that will (if history is any indication) will be implemented poorly and cost taxpayers far more money than it should?

Instead of starting with a solution in search of a problem, maybe we should take a step back, start with a specific problem, and then consider a variety of solutions for that problem that do not themselves make things worse overall. Which problem are we looking to address? Teacher performance? Student performance/behavior? Classroom cleanliness? Assurance of conformance to curriculum? Improvement of evidence quality relating to classroom-based incidents?

Well shit, since it will never work, let's just say "screw it" because what we have is working so well, why offer any thoughts of change?

I'm sure as shit glad multiple people in history just didn't throw up their hands and say **** it, it won't work. :sad:

Like many states, it looks like you've decided parents should have no say in what happens at school. **** the unions, **** protocols, **** what was done for years. Our kids are being manipulated and programmed and sitting back and seeing how it all ends, doesn't sit well with me.

Bill 01-23-2022 11:32pm

This is why I enrolled all my kids in obedience school and doggy daycare, so I could keep an eye on 'em.

ZipZap 01-24-2022 12:19am

Quote:

Originally Posted by aerovette (Post 1936310)
Well shit, since it will never work, let's just say "screw it" because what we have is working so well, why offer any thoughts of change?

I'm sure as shit glad multiple people in history just didn't throw up their hands and say **** it, it won't work. :sad:

Like many states, it looks like you've decided parents should have no say in what happens at school. **** the unions, **** protocols, **** what was done for years. Our kids are being manipulated and programmed and sitting back and seeing how it all ends, doesn't sit well with me.

I would not want strangers seeing my kids, even if I actually had any. Period. If you can figure out a way to strap a gopro to the teacher with the camera pointed inward, then go for it.

Aerovette 01-24-2022 12:36am

Quote:

Originally Posted by ZipZap (Post 1936314)
I would not want strangers seeing my kids, even if I actually had any. Period. If you can figure out a way to strap a gopro to the teacher with the camera pointed inward, then go for it.

How do you keep your kids from being seen by strangers when they are out in public? Kind of like the people that hide their license plate in a post, but drive around all day.:D

Or when they are recorded in a store, or bank, or anywhere alse for that matter?

The people watching are other parents. Are you able to log in to watch your local grocery store?

ZipZap 01-24-2022 3:05am

Quote:

Originally Posted by aerovette (Post 1936315)
How do you keep your kids from being seen by strangers when they are out in public? Kind of like the people that hide their license plate in a post, but drive around all day.:D

Or when they are recorded in a store, or bank, or anywhere alse for that matter?

The people watching are other parents. Are you able to log in to watch your local grocery store?

Kids need to have at least one place that they can go, feel relatively safe, and not be subject to being recorded for what would amount to be eternity. If you think parents would not post this shit up to embarrass little Johnny's "enemies", you are fooling yourself. I agree that we need to figure out a way for teachers to be accountable for their performance, other than being judged by admin that depends on the teacher performance for their own success.

While I have no interest in "logging in" to the grocery store, I'm afraid there may be those who do. Even then, you're talking about a closed system. A school system would be hosted somewhere open, and yes, I could probably get in given some time and spearfishing.

Aerovette 01-24-2022 8:18am

Quote:

Originally Posted by ZipZap (Post 1936316)
Kids need to have at least one place that they can go, feel relatively safe, and not be subject to being recorded for what would amount to be eternity. If you think parents would not post this shit up to embarrass little Johnny's "enemies", you are fooling yourself. I agree that we need to figure out a way for teachers to be accountable for their performance, other than being judged by admin that depends on the teacher performance for their own success.

While I have no interest in "logging in" to the grocery store, I'm afraid there may be those who do. Even then, you're talking about a closed system. A school system would be hosted somewhere open, and yes, I could probably get in given some time and spearfishing.

Yes or no...do cameras make you feel more safe or less safe? Would you feel better knowing your child's day is being monitored, or unchecked?

It's really just that simple. If it is a security concern, fix that concern. Don't throw the baby out with the bathwater. I don't hear about Apple getting hacked. Put them on it. Develop a system like their phones have that are less vulnerable.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 2:06pm.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
User Alert System provided by Advanced User Tagging (Pro) - vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2024 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.
Copyright © 2009 - 2024 The Vette Barn