PDA

View Full Version : New Jersey Justice: Man Convicted of Gun Possession Branded a Felon


Bill
10-20-2013, 10:27am
Father sent to jail and barred from seeing his son for four years after he was found with unloaded gun in back of his car among possessions as he moved house

Brian Aitken was arrested in 2009 as he was moving back from Colorado to New Jersey to be near his child after a divorce
He was later convicted of possessing a gun, sentenced to seven years' prison and banned from seeing his son
Now the New York University graduate and digital media entrepreneur is raising funds so he can write a book about his ordeal
He is also fighting to be reunited with his little boy who is now five

By Helen Pow

PUBLISHED: 21:06 EST, 16 October 2013 | UPDATED: 07:20 EST, 17 October 2013

A desperate father has been banned from seeing his young son for four years after he was found with an unloaded gun he legally owned in the back of his car among his possessions as he moved house.
Brian Aitken was arrested in 2009 as he was moving back from Colorado to New Jersey to be near his child after a divorce. He was later convicted of possessing a gun and sentenced to seven years' prison.
Now the New York University graduate and digital media entrepreneur is using a crowdfunding website to raise funds so he can write a book about his ordeal and hopefully be reunited with his little boy.
The saga began when Aitken's mother called 911 after he arrived with his possessions piled high at her house in New Jersey, but she didn't complete the call. The police arrived regardless and after questioning her she explained that she was concerned for Aitken's welfare following his divorce.

The officers then called Aitken, who by that stage had left, and coerced him to return. When he arrived, the officers searched his car and found three locked, unloaded handguns in the trunk. He was then arrested.

In his trial, Aitken explained he was in the process of moving from Colorado to New Jersey, which is an accepted exemption under the state's law. He even called the New Jersey State Police before he set off and asked them how to transport his firearms.

'I did exactly what they told me to do,' he said.
The jury asked if they could take the exemption into account but the judge refused. The father was convicted and sentenced to seven years prison.
'After I was indicted of a victimless and violentless charge, with no prior criminal record, a family judge interpreted the charge to mean that I was a violent criminal with access to firearms and that fathers who own guns pose a threat to their children,' he told Ammoland.

Although Governor Chris Christie commuted Aitken's sentence after he had spent four months, and his 27th birthday, in prison, his saga continues.

He is still labeled a felon and therefore cannot own a gun, cannot vote, and cannot travel overseas because his passport was revoked.
Desperate: Aitken, pictured with his new partner Jenna, is determined to get his son back and has raised more than $26,000 on Indiegogo
Supreme Court: Aitken, again pictured with Jenna, wants to take his case to the Supreme Court
More importantly, he is still unable to see his son, who is now five years old, because he cannot meet the harsh restrictions the judge placed on him.

Aitken's attorney described the case as a 'perfect storm of injustice,' to Crowdfund Insider
He now travels around the U.S. raising awareness about what happened to him and the huge ramifications it has had on his life. His story has also been covered in print, online and TV media.

In his latest push, he is raising funds on crowdfunding website Indiegogo to write a book about his experience and to be able to take his case to the Supreme Court.

With a week left in the campaign he has surpassed his initial $20,000 goal but is hoping to double that.

On his campaign page he writes: 'Until my case is resolved I can't vote or pass a background check. It's next to impossible to get a credit card or even sign a lease for an apartment. I can't leave the country and I can't see my son. Clearing my name is the first step towards getting my life back... and I can't do it without your help.'


Read more: Brian Aitken: Father sent to jail and barred from seeing son for possessing gun | Mail Online (http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2463994/Brian-Aitken-Father-sent-jail-barred-seeing-son-possessing-gun.html#ixzz2iH9ehztz)
Follow us: @MailOnline on Twitter | DailyMail on Facebook

All along the chain of events is FAIL. The vindictive ex wife might have wanted to screw the now ex, but, how is she going to get child support from a guy in prison who can't earn a living? Fail. The cops that came could have used a little common sense. It was clear the guy was moving, and that the guns were properly stowed and not a threat, yet they felt the need to arrest him anyway. Fail. The prosecuter could have declined to prosecute the case, in the interest of justice, but decided to prosecute anyway. Fail. The judge could have instructed the jury that the travelling exemption was an affirmative defense, but chose not to. Fail. The jury themselves could have said, "Is this right? Do we really need to jail this guy and brand him a felon?"
That jury could have acquitted or jury nullified.....but they didn't. Fail. And finally, the governor could have pardoned him, but instead let him languish in prison for 4 months before commuting the sentence. Fail.

WTF? What are the odds that that much fail happens in one case?

Also, tangentally, would it be bad of me to wish that something awful happens to the ex, the arresting officers, the prosecutor, judge, jury, and governor? Because I kinda feel that way.

Cybercowboy
10-20-2013, 10:42am
That is seriously f-ed up. We have 5% of the world's population, but 25% of the the total people in prison. We have 25% of the world's lawyers, and prosecuting attorneys win 99.5% of their cases here (either by conviction or plea bargain.) That's 99.5%. You do not want to test the waters of our criminal "justice" system.

Bill
10-20-2013, 10:49am
That is seriously f-ed up. We have 5% of the world's population, but 25% of the the total people in prison. We have 25% of the world's lawyers, and prosecuting attorneys win 99.5% of their cases here (either by conviction or plea bargain.) That's 99.5%. You do not want to test the waters of our criminal "justice" system.

The voters of New Jersey voted for the people who made the laws that branded this guy a felon. The overwhelming fail belongs to them.

All along the process, we hoped that someone would chose NOT to be a mindless automaton and employ common sense. Too many folks are apparently not capable of independent thought, which is why draconian laws against victimless and non violent acts are on the books in the first place, and obviously why this guy's life has been ruined.

Marc
10-20-2013, 11:27am
"The saga began when Aitken's mother called 911 after he arrived with his possessions piled high at her house in New Jersey, but she didn't complete the call. The police arrived regardless and after questioning her she explained that she was concerned for Aitken's welfare following his divorce."

His own mother, unknowingly, threw her son under the bus with her concern for his well being. This forced the officers to act in some way, I'm sure of it. They should have taken possession of the firearms rather then arrest the individual. And it does not matter what state you are in, if your own mother tells the police she is worried about state of mind/well being, they must act. But all things being equal, NJ owes this man some serious coin and I hope he gets it as well as wiping his record clean.

Bill
10-20-2013, 11:33am
"The saga began when Aitken's mother called 911 after he arrived with his possessions piled high at her house in New Jersey, but she didn't complete the call. The police arrived regardless and after questioning her she explained that she was concerned for Aitken's welfare following his divorce."

His own mother, unknowingly, threw her son under the bus with her concern for his well being. This forced the officers to act in some way, I'm sure of it. They should have taken possession of the firearms rather then arrest the individual. And it does not matter what state you are in, if your own mother tells the police she is worried about state of mind/well being, they must act. But all things being equal, NJ owes this man some serious coin and I hope he gets it as well as wiping his record clean.

Thanks for the save. I misread that to read that the ex wife did it, when in fact it was his mom. I'm sure mom feels a lot of guilt.

Marc
10-20-2013, 11:38am
I would like to have heard to conversation between the officers and the mother after the 911 hangup. She probably needed a lawyer and didn't even know it, with the questions the police were asking.

island14
10-20-2013, 11:42am
This is all kinds of messed up :(

Most the time you never hear about it, but you can bet things like this and other messed up wrongs happen all the time.

Torqaholic
10-20-2013, 10:26pm
This is all kinds of messed up :(

Most the time you never hear about it, but you can bet things like this and other messed up wrongs happen all the time.

Yup, and everybody that lacks such an experience thinks it can't happen to them until it does. Then it's too late and they're on their own against this evil. They don't realize they're standing in line waiting their turn to be raped by the injustice system... Not a freaking clue :rofl:

PortDawg
10-21-2013, 4:31am
The 2nd Amendment has been summarily revoked in NY and NJ. Sad that this is allowed to continue.

island14
10-21-2013, 7:12am
The 2nd Amendment has been summarily revoked in NY and NJ. Sad that this is allowed to continue.

I wonder about his 4th also.. :yesnod:


Did he give them consent to search I wonder? :island14:

When he arrived, the officers searched his car and found three locked, unloaded handguns in the trunk. He was then arrested.

Fastguy
10-21-2013, 7:35am
Sadly, this sort of injustice is most common in NJ, NY, and MA due to the assinine gun laws that destroy people's lives over victimless crimes.