Ok J-Frame Carriers....

[Jeff '79]

What IWB holster do you prefer the best?
I'm looking at the Bianchi Pro 100 , but have not tried one yet.

http://i999.photobucket.com/albums/af113/jeff79/Bianchi100Pro_zpsf8f56464.jpg

[Sea Six]

I just REALLY don't like any concealed carry holster with a belt clip. I just keep thinking that, in the heat of the moment, what with the adrenaline and all... it's just very possible to draw the gun, holster and all... and not be able to shoot because you can't put your finger in the trigger guard.

I know... I'm in the minority opinion on this one.

[badbirdcage]

I just REALLY don't like any concealed carry holster with a belt clip. I just keep thinking that, in the heat of the moment, what with the adrenaline and all... it's just very possible to draw the gun, holster and all... and not be able to shoot because you can't put your finger in the trigger guard.

I know... I'm in the minority opinion on this one.

Actually I do not think you should be in the minority. If there is a belt LOOP on the inside the pants holster you are good as long as it is retained with the belt through the loop. The clip style can be defeated and it has happened to me on the firing range. Better there than when I really might need it.

AND I have observed the same situation with other people at the range.

[Fastguy]

I use a really wide nylon through the belt OWB. I can't wear an IWB.

[Sea Six]

I use a really wide nylon through the belt OWB. I can't wear an IWB.

Why not?

[Jeff '79]

:waiting:

[xXBUDXx]

Why not?

He has "birthing hips" and the bulge of the holster makes his makes his space suit bunch up. :D

[SnikPlosskin]

I just REALLY don't like any concealed carry holster with a belt clip. I just keep thinking that, in the heat of the moment, what with the adrenaline and all... it's just very possible to draw the gun, holster and all... and not be able to shoot because you can't put your finger in the trigger guard.

I know... I'm in the minority opinion on this one.

I've never had that issue. :confused5:

My crossbreed supertuck combined with Galco "cop belt" stays put. A belt clip with the flange at the bottom should lock on the belt (assuming you have the right belt - but I know Thomas does)

I have one similar to the OP photo and it stays put too.

Down side of clips on mag holders is I break them off getting in the car. Especially plastic ones.

Thomas, why do you think you have the issue? Retention too tight? Just curious.

[Fastguy]

He has "birthing hips" and the bulge of the holster makes his makes his space suit bunch up. :D


:lol:
Something like that. When I wear one, it makes me look like I have a giant tumor, easier to just wear a jacket or overshirt.

[Jeff '79]

I just don't want to go through 6 different holsters, before I find the right one.. I have an IWB clip on for my LC-9, and ya, they're not the ideal situation, but I prefer the convenience if it.

[Norm]

Prefer the outside belt loop holster with a thumb break retention snap, works best for me. Want that holster to stay put.

[Sea Six]

I just don't want to go through 6 different holsters, before I find the right one.. I have an IWB clip on for my LC-9, and ya, they're not the ideal situation, but I prefer the convenience if it.

:funnier:

You will soon have an entire dresser drawer-full of holsters, just like the rest of us.

:seasix:


It's just the way it works. :)

[Torqaholic]

Don't ask me, only revolver I carry is an N-Frame :lol:

I'm still using these for my carry needs: FIST, INC. (http://www.fist-inc.com/holsters/holster/42.htm).

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v169/Venomenon/Gunz/FIST42.jpg

I don't wear as intended however (too floppy). I wear OWB but strapped under the belt with the plastic back used as a paddle. There's a hook on it which locks into the top of the pants pocket on the inside making the holster impossible to work loose. Since I lack an ass I'm always hiking my pants up whether carrying or not... But I never need to readjust the holster (couldn't if I tried :rofl:).

If that's confusing here's a picture -

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v169/Venomenon/Gunz/xd9ccw.jpg

[Torqaholic]

you can't put your finger in the trigger guard.

I know... I'm in the minority opinion on this one.

:rofl: Nope. I bought one of those kind of holsters as a temporary solution until my custom arrived once. I think it only fell out onto the ground two or three times.

[Sea Six]

:rofl: Nope. I bought one of those kind of holsters as a temporary solution until my custom arrived once. I think it only fell out onto the ground two or three times.

:seasix:

Also, those types of holsters in the OP don't hold the gun in a fixed position. They can rotate back and forth, requiring you to make periodic adjustments to keep it where you can draw it and reholster effectively.

These constant adjusting movements can also divulge the fact that you're carrying, which is contrary to the goal of carrying concealed and could lead to an arrest in certain areas.

[Jeff '79]

:funnier:

You will soon have an entire dresser drawer-full of holsters, just like the rest of us.

:seasix:


It's just the way it works. :)

Ya, I'm trying to avoid that.....:yesnod:

Here's a Masters IWB that looks promising. Sorry, the pic was funky, so there's a link.Inside the Waist Band (IWB) Concealment Holster with belt straps (http://www.jbpholsters.com/servlet/the-97/LEATHER-GUN-HOLSTER-MASTER/Detail#ReviewHeader)

And a Don Hume that looks good.H715-M W.C. [H715-M] - $33.60 : Don Hume Leathergoods, manufactures high quality leather and nylon goods. (http://www.donhume.com/index.php?main_page=product_info&cPath=65_5&products_id=35)

http://i999.photobucket.com/albums/af113/jeff79/DonHumeIWB_zps6487a9c3.jpg

[Sea Six]

Jeff, one thing that is very important in a concealed carry holster is the ability to reholster quickly, with one hand and with no fumbling. Very few holsters that are inside the waistband that are not using kydex in some way meet that requirement.

The Minotaur holster by Comp-tac is my absolute favorite IWB model. I am unable to find anything I don't like about it. You can even tuck your shirt into your waistband over it. The way the clips attach to the belt, both at the top and the bottom, ensures the angle of the gun stays put.

It is extremely comfortable because the part that touches your body (or undershirt in my case) is all leather, which flexes a little as you move. The way the angle of the gun (the cant) is set is permanent so it doesn't rock forward or backward... set it and forget it.

http://www.comp-tac.com/product_info.php?products_id=95&osCsid=6rlgah6edc9m2lb1r3mb6djqi1

[TripleBlack]

Ya, I'm trying to avoid that.....:yesnod:

Here's a Masters IWB that looks promising. Sorry, the pic was funky, so there's a link.Inside the Waist Band (IWB) Concealment Holster with belt straps (http://www.jbpholsters.com/servlet/the-97/LEATHER-GUN-HOLSTER-MASTER/Detail#ReviewHeader)

And a Don Hume that looks good.H715-M W.C. [H715-M] - $33.60 : Don Hume Leathergoods, manufactures high quality leather and nylon goods. (http://www.donhume.com/index.php?main_page=product_info&cPath=65_5&products_id=35)

http://i999.photobucket.com/albums/af113/jeff79/DonHumeIWB_zps6487a9c3.jpg

I have that Don Hume for a Glock 27. The belt clip is sturdy, and on a good belt, it's never felt insecure, however, I wish it had loops as it does permit the gun to cant forwards or backwards at bit. Actually, I don't mind that so much as it allows for a bit of adjustment when sitting but it doesn't feel as secure as my Milt Sparks Summer Special with loops. If I was only going to have one holster, it would be the Milt Sparks, but don't know if they make a J-frame version.

BTW, the Don Hume does stay 'open' so you can re-holster with one hand.

[Jeff '79]

Well.... I just ordered this one... Don Hume H715 M Conceal Carry Holster Fit 3 2 for s w 36 37 2" BL Brown | eBay (http://www.ebay.com/itm/Don-Hume-H715-M-Conceal-Carry-Holster-fit-3-2-for-S-W-36-37-2-BL-Brown-/230735630839)

For $27.00 to my door, we'll see. Hopefully it isn't the start of a collection.
I got the brown one.

http://i999.photobucket.com/albums/af113/jeff79/just-about-perfect-cover_zps922ffc99.jpg

http://i999.photobucket.com/albums/af113/jeff79/DonHumeIWB_zps6487a9c3.jpg

[TripleBlack]

Well.... I just ordered this one... Don Hume H715 M Conceal Carry Holster Fit 3 2 for s w 36 37 2" BL Brown | eBay (http://www.ebay.com/itm/Don-Hume-H715-M-Conceal-Carry-Holster-fit-3-2-for-S-W-36-37-2-BL-Brown-/230735630839)

For $27.00 to my door, we'll see. Hopefully it isn't the start of a collection.
I got the brown one.

http://i999.photobucket.com/albums/af113/jeff79/just-about-perfect-cover_zps922ffc99.jpg

http://i999.photobucket.com/albums/af113/jeff79/DonHumeIWB_zps6487a9c3.jpg

Hard to beat for the $$$, IMO. Mine fits the Glock really well and is much better made than the price would suggest. :cert:

[Jeff '79]

Hard to beat for the $$$, IMO. Mine fits the Glock really well and is much better made than the price would suggest. :cert:

Don Hume makes a really good product. My only worry is that reholstering will be tough, as the top would collapse from the tightness of the belt. It is a pita to reholster behind the back, no matter what, but that's how I roll though, so we'll see.....
And ya, for the price, it won't be as painful if I have to drawer it.:cert:

[TripleBlack]

Don Hume makes a really good product. My only worry is that reholstering will be tough, as the top would collapse from the tightness of the belt. It is a pita to reholster behind the back, no matter what, but that's how I roll though, so we'll see.....
And ya, for the price, it won't be as painful if I have to drawer it.:cert:

I can reholster the 27 in the Don Hume one handed on a side carry which probably puts more tension on the holster opening that carry in the back would. It does take some effort, though ... not a quick smooth motion. My Hume has what I think is a metal spring sewn into the opening - not as strong by a good bit as the one in my Milt Sparks, but adequate.

Reholstering a revolver may take a bit more finesse though, especially behind the back.

Wish the most expensive holster in my unused drawer cost only $27. You did good.

[69camfrk]

I just REALLY don't like any concealed carry holster with a belt clip. I just keep thinking that, in the heat of the moment, what with the adrenaline and all... it's just very possible to draw the gun, holster and all... and not be able to shoot because you can't put your finger in the trigger guard.

I know... I'm in the minority opinion on this one.

No...no you're not. I won't wear one with a belt clip anymore for that reason.:seasix:

[Jeff '79]

I just REALLY don't like any concealed carry holster with a belt clip. I just keep thinking that, in the heat of the moment, what with the adrenaline and all... it's just very possible to draw the gun, holster and all... and not be able to shoot because you can't put your finger in the trigger guard.

I know... I'm in the minority opinion on this one.

Actually I do not think you should be in the minority. If there is a belt LOOP on the inside the pants holster you are good as long as it is retained with the belt through the loop. The clip style can be defeated and it has happened to me on the firing range. Better there than when I really might need it.

AND I have observed the same situation with other people at the range.

No...no you're not. I won't wear one with a belt clip anymore for that reason.:seasix:

This has happened to me in practice, however it was because the clip was not on my belt right. After a lot of trial and error, placing the holster in different places on my back, I have found the sweet spot where it is totally comfortable, and stays put all the time. The draw is perfect, and I can now reholster on one try. Once I found the sweet spot, and practiced, it just became natural muscle memory. The clip stays on the belt now, where before it sometimes didn't. Placement, and proper clip application to your belt, are key to a holster that not only stays put, but that you are able to reholster easily.
It took a bit of time to get it right, but I'm very comfortable with this right now..
http://i999.photobucket.com/albums/af113/jeff79/DSC05255.jpg
http://i999.photobucket.com/albums/af113/jeff79/DSC05256.jpg

[badbirdcage]

If you're happy I'm happy for you.

As an aside remember that when the fecal material hits the rotating cooling device nothing is going to go perfectly. Possibly even your positioning of the holster clip that you have defeated in the past. I wish you only good fortune.

[69camfrk]

Here is what I use when I carry my 642.:seasix:

http://i76.photobucket.com/albums/j17/69camfrk/006-1.jpg