Log in

View Full Version : Battle of Antietam 150th


Grey Ghost
09-16-2012, 2:14pm
I participated in the 135th reenactment. Wasn't able to attend the 150th this weekend. Just a few highlights of the battle.

It was the bloodiest single-day battle in American history, with about 23,000 casualties on both sides.

September 17, 1862.

"Artillery Hell" - As quoted from one Confed. officer. The union had and estimated 293 guns. The Confederates had and estimated 246 pcs. It is estimated 50,000 artillery projectiles were fired during the battle and 3-4 million bullets.

During our reenactment, they could hear the cannonade all the way to Wash. I can't remember how many cannons participated. But, as per the original battle, they opened up with everything at 5:30 am that Sept. morning and it continued for hours. I will NEVER forget the concussion feeling of being in-between all those guns.

The Cornfield - Seeing the glint of Confederate bayonets concealed in the Cornfield, Hooker halted his infantry and brought up four batteries of artillery, which fired shell and canister over the heads of the Federal infantry, covering the field. All at once, the cornfield exploded into chaos as a savage battle raged through the area. Men beat each other over the heads with rifle butts and stabbed each other with bayonets. Officers rode around on their horses sweating and cursing and yelling orders no one could hear in the noise. Rifles became hot and fouled from too much firing. The air was filled with a hail of bullets and shells.

Remember, it was almost still pitch dark that early morning and the corn was still high in the field. We even had tons of confusion during the reenactment of this portion of the battle. I can't imagine the kind of hell the real soldiers experienced that morning. :sadangel:

Bloody Lane - The Confeds. held a great position during a good part of the battle. It was a sunken road below a small hill. As the Feds. came over the top of a hill. They were practically mowed down with fire from the sunken road. There is a famous photo of Confed. dead in Bloody Lane. There was miscommunication about adjusting the battle line and it left a hole in the Confed. line and the Feds. finally pushed through to take the position.

Burnside's Bridge - 400 men of the 2nd and 20th Georgia regiments, under the command of Brig. Gen. Robert Toombs, with two artillery batteries held off 12,500 Fed. troops and 50 artillery pcs. for three hours at this position. The bridge actually had another name, but, has always been called this since the battle. Basically, Burnside, tried to move all his men over this tiny bridge into action. It was a huge bottleneck and he was criticized for not having his men wade through the creek that was only waist deep. On the other side were VERY steep banks that were practically impossible for anyone to climb...especially with all their accoutrements on and muskets.

A.P. Hill - A.P. Hill moved his Division 17 miles from Harpers Ferry, at a wicked pace. Some said he would slap stragglers across the butt with the back of his sword to keep them moving. He realized the seriousness of getting his men there and into line of battle. He was ordered to reinforce the Confed. right and instead of waiting for his entire Div. to arrive (which was proper procedure) deployed them into battle line as they arrived. Burnside's plan was to hit the weakened Confed. right and flank them. They ran smack dab into A.P. Hill's men which ended the battle.

It is another one of those 'what if' questions that the CW is famous for...What if... A.P. Hill hadn't made it there in time ? What if... Burnside had gotten his men across that little bridge and into line earlier in the day ?

Lee withdrew back to VA. the next day. Union Gen. McClellan was relieved of duty for not pursuing them. Lincoln issued the Emancipation Proclamation on September 22.

Spare a moment of silent thought or prayer for these men tomorrow. :sadangel: Don't forget them and what they sacrificed for all of us.

Timeline, maps, pics, etc...
Battle of Antietam - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

lspencer534
09-16-2012, 2:27pm
There was a long and very interesting article in the newspaper here today about it. It said that a new exhibit opened last month in Frederick. The exhibit's centerpiece is a two-page document: Robert E. Lee's secret Special Orders No. 191. It detaild an audacious plan for the invasion of enemy territory that would propel the Confederacy to victory. It detailed Lee's attack on Maryland and what each division of his army would do.

Carelessly it was dropped on the ground as Lee moved North and was found by troops from Indiana. General McClellan looked at the papers and caught Lee in his own trap.

RIP, soldiers. :sadangel:

OddBall
09-16-2012, 5:05pm
:BADRACR1: :sadangel: :USA:
:halfmast:

Skia
09-16-2012, 5:22pm
:sadangel: :BADRACR1:

Grey Ghost
09-16-2012, 6:32pm
:yesnod: It was a general movement order for the Confed. army. Gen. McClellan thought it may have been deliberately planted as a trap and failed to exploit the information.

There was a long and very interesting article in the newspaper here today about it. It said that a new exhibit opened last month in Frederick. The exhibit's centerpiece is a two-page document: Robert E. Lee's secret Special Orders No. 191. It detaild an audacious plan for the invasion of enemy territory that would propel the Confederacy to victory. It detailed Lee's attack on Maryland and what each division of his army would do.

Carelessly it was dropped on the ground as Lee moved North and was found by troops from Indiana. General McClellan looked at the papers and caught Lee in his own trap.

RIP, soldiers. :sadangel:

Allan
09-16-2012, 6:57pm
This story was on PBS last night. Several of the narraters were college history prof's.

Bucwheat
09-16-2012, 7:11pm
I have an original 1865 Atlanta news paper and it's one thing to read about it in history books but when you read the stories first hand,well there is a certain thrill for me,love that civil war stuff.:seasix:

lspencer534
09-16-2012, 7:15pm
:yesnod: It was a general movement order for the Confed. army. Gen. McClellan thought it may have been deliberately planted as a trap and failed to exploit the information.

I did not know that. It was reported as "fact" in the newspaper and as a decisive moment in the war.

Dan Dlabay
09-16-2012, 7:17pm
It's a shame that it took the Civil War to keep this country together as a Union.May God bless all the men and women on both sides that fought in this war.:sadangel::USA::halfmast:

lspencer534
09-16-2012, 7:20pm
It's a shame that it took the Civil War to keep this country together as a Union.May God bless all the men and women on both sides that fought in this war.:sadangel::USA::halfmast:

I'm glad you mentioned the women. Not only did they serve support roles, many women pretended to be men and fought in battle.

69camfrk
09-16-2012, 7:27pm
The south is gonna win round II!!!!!!:seasix:

lspencer534
09-16-2012, 7:36pm
The south is gonna win round II!!!!!!:seasix:

Hell...we just might! I hope it never comes to that, but secession is sounding better every day. If Texas kicks it off, there's going to be a lot of followers.

Grey Ghost
09-16-2012, 8:35pm
Clara Barton is too often overlooked for her contributions. The strain on the family back at home is also overlooked. Some wives stayed with their husband during winter camp, when close to home, etc...

I'm glad you mentioned the women. Not only did they serve support roles, many women pretended to be men and fought in battle.

VITE1
09-17-2012, 7:06am
The Civil war change American Military philosophy, and the worlds, profoundly. The massive lose of life during the war and the technology advances we had changed the face of war forever.

For the men who paid the ultimate Price 150 years ago.
:sadangel::sadangel::sadangel:

island14
09-17-2012, 7:16am
C'mon Ghost.... :toetap:

Pics? :island14:

Grey Ghost
09-17-2012, 7:39pm
Photography was still fairly new technology during the CW. A few photographers followed the armies and took photos. They would return to a large city and put the photos on display and charge an admission price. People were very eager to see these. Remember, most were only use to seeing engravings and drawings, due to photography still being fairly new. You can imagine the shock of seeing bullet riddled clothing, dried blood, bloating, disfigurement, etc...from war wounds. A lot of precious images were lost after the war. The glass plate that the image was exposed on was worth more money than the image itself at the time. Some people used them for window panes and their garden sun houses...I have included some of the originals below. These were probably taken a couple of days after the battle. Also, a link to some modern day pics and a link to the LOC/pictures page. A man started collecting interesting CW images about 20 yrs. ago. He donated them to the LOC. I've seen original glass plate images in person. The clarity on some is scary. Waaay clearer and detailed than you would think.

One more story...back in 2008 a park visitor discovered a bone in the walkway. They carried it up to the visitor center to the park rangers. The rangers made note of the spot and an excavation was started. They carefully removed layers of soil until they saw nine buttons in perfect alignment. Just below the buttons was a US belt buckle with leather still attached to it. They also discovered more bone fragments and skull. The buttons were NY State buttons. After much research of the OR's(original battle reports from the field) the position of the bones, etc...they identified the remains to a 19 yr. old union soldier from New York. The Gov. of NY was notified and asked if he would like the remains returned home. The reply was a resounding yes. The remains were returned and given a full military burial. No one had a clue this soldier was buried in this spot for almost 150 yrs. That is why when you walk on these battlefields. You are walking on sacred ground. :sadangel:

C'mon Ghost.... :toetap:
Pics? :island14:

Retracing The Steps Of A Civil War Photographer : NPR (http://www.npr.org/2012/09/17/161167847/re-tracing-the-steps-of-a-civil-war-photographer)

Liljenquist Family Collection of Civil War Photographs - About this Collection - Prints & Photographs Online Catalog (Library of Congress) (http://www.loc.gov/pictures/collection/lilj/)

http://www.civilwarphotos.net/files/images/285.jpg

http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/e/ec/Antietam-Bridge-Gardner.jpeg

http://www.xtimeline.com/__UserPic_Large/9015/ELT200805042304564339949.JPG

http://www.iub.edu/~imaghist/images/bttlfldlttrs/cnfdrtddanttm.jpg

http://www.sonofthesouth.net/leefoundation/Antietam/dead-soldier-antietam.jpg

http://0.tqn.com/d/history1800s/1/0/r/D/-/-/angard-unburied01.jpg

http://msnbcmedia.msn.com/i/MSNBC/Components/Photo/_new/pb-120915-civil-cannon2.jpg

Entropy
09-17-2012, 7:45pm
This thread made me queue up The Civil War by Ken Burns on Netflix. :cheers: